Ioan Davies All articles
Growth Strategy

The Invoice Is Not the Problem: Buying Advice That Actually Earns Its Keep

Ioan Davies
The Invoice Is Not the Problem: Buying Advice That Actually Earns Its Keep

Photo: Reinhard Kirchner, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Most consultancy invoices are not dishonest. They are vague. And vague is expensive.

I have sat through plenty of UK small-business strategy sessions where the room was warm, the biscuits were good and the output was a set of slides that nobody opened again. I have also seen a two-hour conversation, properly scoped, kill a bad idea before it cost anyone a penny in stock, staff or software. The difference is rarely the day rate. It is the shape of the work.

What you are really paying for

When advice earns its keep, you are buying four things. First, diagnosis: someone who can spot the pattern you are too close to see. Second, prioritisation: the nerve to say 'not now' to three good ideas so one can actually happen. Third, a plan with names and dates attached. Fourth, a bit of spine when the plan meets a busy Tuesday and everyone wants to go back to the old way.

You are not paying for words per minute. You are not paying for a tour of the consultant's favourite framework. You are not paying for someone to agree with you in a nicer meeting room.

A good outsider should make your business simpler, not more dependent on them. If the work leaves you with a longer to-do list and a shorter temper, the invoice may be honest but the value is not.

What you should not pay for

There are a few things that should set off alarm bells on any consultancy quote.

None of these are necessarily dishonest. They are just expensive ways of avoiding the real job: making a decision under uncertainty and helping you stick to it.

The expensive echo test

How do you tell a useful outsider from an expensive echo? Ask three questions before you hire, and listen carefully to the answers.

  1. When did you last tell a client something they did not want to hear?
  2. Can you describe a trade-off you would recommend for a business like mine?
  3. What would you leave out of scope, and why?

A useful outsider will have examples. They will talk about the client who wanted to expand too fast, the website that was hiding a pricing problem, or the team that needed fewer projects, not more. An expensive echo will tell you that every business is unique, then recommend the same five things anyway.

The one-page brief to use before you hire

Before you ask for a proposal, write a one-page brief. Keep it plain. If a consultant will not engage with a brief like this, that is useful information in itself.

The decision I need to make: What exactly are you trying to decide? Be specific. 'Whether to open a second site' is better than 'growth strategy'.

The outcome I want by a date: What should be different by, say, the end of March? More enquiries, fewer returns, a new service launched, a decision made?

What we have already tried: Include the things that did not work. It saves everyone time and money.

The constraints: Budget, people, cash, stock, seasonality, family commitments, the lot. Constraints are not moaning; they are the brief.

Who owns this internally: A name, not a department. If nobody owns it, it will not happen.

What success looks like in numbers: Pick one or two measures. They can be rough. 'Ten more enquiries a month' is fine. 'Better brand presence' is not.

What is out of scope: Say it plainly. This is how you avoid paying for a new logo when you asked for a pricing review.

How we will work: Meetings, access to staff, deliverables, decision points. Keep it short enough to read.

Fee and payment: Tie payment to milestones where you can. A small deposit is normal. A large upfront fee for a vague outcome is not.

What would make us stop: Agree this early. If the work is not landing, both sides should be able to say so without a drama.

Buy the outcome, not the performance

Consultancy is not magic and it is not charity. You should pay well for sharp thinking, honest challenge and someone who helps you get something done. You should not pay for the theatre of being advised.

Start small. Scope tightly. Ask for a decision, a date and a measure. If the invoice buys you a clearer head and a shorter list of priorities, it has probably earned its keep. If it buys you a deck and a follow-up meeting, push back.

That is not anti-consultant. It is pro-good advice. The two are not the same thing.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Shopkeeper's Advantage: Why Local Credibility Still Beats the Algorithm

The Shopkeeper's Advantage: Why Local Credibility Still Beats the Algorithm

The Cheapest Fix for a Wobbly Website: Five Customer Calls

The Cheapest Fix for a Wobbly Website: Five Customer Calls

Seven Quiet Hours: The Admin Audit You Can Finish Before Friday

Seven Quiet Hours: The Admin Audit You Can Finish Before Friday