The Cheapest Fix for a Wobbly Website: Five Customer Calls
Photo: Gage Skidmore from Surprise, AZ, United States of America, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Here is the cheapest audit I know for a UK small business: ring five recent customers before you spend a penny on a rebrand or a new website.
Not a survey. Not a focus group with a flip chart and disappointing biscuits. Five short calls, one notebook, and a willingness to hear something you would rather not hear.
I have seen firms spend five figures on a new site because the old one 'felt tired', then discover afterwards that customers were actually confused about delivery times, opening hours or whether they sold to the trade. A week of phone calls would have told them that for the price of a few cups of tea.
Why five calls?
Five is small enough to actually do and large enough to hear a pattern. You are not trying to produce a statistically perfect piece of research. You are trying to replace assumption with evidence.
Pick a mix: two people who bought recently, one who asked a lot of questions before buying, one who has bought more than once, and one who went quiet after an enquiry. Keep it to fifteen minutes each. Ask permission. Say you are reviewing how the business comes across and you are not trying to sell anything.
The two questions to ask
You only need two core questions. Everything else is follow-up.
Question one: 'What were you trying to get done on the day you found us?'
This is not the same as 'why did you buy?' It gets at the job in hand. Were they replacing a broken part? Getting ready for an audit? Feeding a family on a Friday? Trying to look less amateur before a big client meeting? The words they use are gold. They are the words your website should use.
Question two: 'What almost stopped you from buying, or made it harder than it needed to be?'
This is where the useful pain lives. Maybe they could not tell if you delivered to their postcode. Maybe the enquiry form asked for a company registration number they did not have. Maybe they rang twice and nobody picked up. Maybe they nearly went with a cheaper competitor because your prices were hidden.
Do not argue. Do not explain. Do not say 'ah, but that is because...' Just write it down and ask 'what else?'
Listen for the gap
The gap is the space between what your business assumes and what customers actually experience. It is usually not dramatic. It is a sentence on a homepage, a missing FAQ, a phone number in the wrong place or a checkout step that feels like a form for the tax office.
Listen for phrases like:
- 'I did not realise you did that.'
- 'I nearly went with someone else because...'
- 'I had to ring to check...'
- 'I was not sure what happened next.'
- 'My mate recommended you.'
- 'I could not find your prices.'
Each one is a clue. If three people mention the same thing, it is not a one-off. It is a pattern, and patterns are where the money is.
Turn five calls into one action list
Within forty-eight hours, write a one-page action list. Keep it simple: what we heard, what it means, what we will change, who owns it, and when it will be done. Pick no more than five actions for the next month.
Examples might include:
- Rewrite the first line of the homepage so it says what you actually do.
- Add a short FAQ about delivery, lead times or minimum order values.
- Put the phone number at the top of every page.
- Add a 'what happens next' paragraph after the enquiry form.
- Publish three real examples of work, with the customer's permission.
- Fix the opening hours on Google and on your own site.
- Change the enquiry form so it asks fewer questions.
None of that requires a new brand, a new platform or a six-month project. It requires paying attention.
What not to do
Do not turn this into a survey with twenty questions. Do not ask leading questions like 'you found the website easy, didn't you?' Do not outsource it to a market research firm if you are a five-person business. Do not use the answers to justify the rebrand you had already decided to buy. And do not ignore the one negative comment because it came from a customer who was a bit grumpy. Grumpy customers are often the most specific.
When a new website is the right answer
Sometimes it is. If your site cannot take payments, breaks on a phone, or makes you look like a different business, a rebuild may be overdue. But a new website will not fix an unclear offer. It will just make the confusion faster and more expensive.
The best brief for a web designer is not a mood board. It is a page of customer language, a list of the five things customers actually need to know, and evidence of where they get stuck.
Five calls, one page, one month. It is cheaper than a rebrand and far more likely to tell you what to fix. And if you are nervous about ringing customers, start with the ones who already like you. They will usually take the call.